On the Record: SeaRey—Kentucky

Aug. 15, 2015

The pilot of the amphibious airplane stated that after a normal touchdown on a river, “5–10 seconds later we were upside down.” The pilot and passenger were able to exit the airplane into the water, and a nearby boater came to their assistance.

The pilot stated that he believed he struck a submerged object in the water.

According to an FAA aviation safety inspector, the right side of the airplane showed evidence that it struck an object submerged in the water. The FAA inspector also reported that he was informed of numerous recreational boats striking debris near the accident site earlier in the day.

NTSB Final Report

Ron Wanttaja
Ron Wanttaja
Ron Wanttaja is a retired space systems engineer. During a 40-year career, he helped design, build, test, launch, and operate 18 spacecraft, including the International Space Station. On the aviation side, he has owned a Bowers Fly Baby since 1996 and flew the original prototype for seven years before acquiring his own. He lives just outside of Portland, Oregon, with his wife, romance novelist Lisa McAllister.

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Latest
Related

6 COMMENTS

Subscribe to this comment thread
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Jay
Jay
20 days ago

I’m sure it’s must be tempting to try it out and sea what your new boat plane is capable of. But an airplane was made to fly, not swim. 🏊 It’s like buying a shiny new 4wd pickup with a beautiful paint job and then deciding “hey, let’s cut through the woods and see if the stump jumper works.”

Ron Wanttaja
Reply to  Jay
19 days ago

I gave a presentation earlier this year for the EAA Homebuilt Week, where I presented the fleet accident rate for various homebuilt types. The Searey came out at about 1% of the fleet having an accident every year, vs. the ~0.70% average for the overall homebuilts.

However, fully *half* of the Searey accidents involved water operations…leaving the gear down for a water landing, encountering boat wakes or sunken logs, etc.

Living in the Pacific Northwest for the past 40+ years, I get the appeal of airplanes that can operate off water. So I don’t fault the Searey for a higher accident rate due to more-risky modes of operation.

Lumpy
Lumpy
Reply to  Jay
18 days ago

I don’t know why someone would buy a seaplane and not use it on water. Or a 4×4 and not use it off road.

Anyway, I’m glad they both got out. Maybe it’s time to mark the spot where numerous recreational boats and an airplane all struck debris in a single day.

Jay
Jay
Reply to  Lumpy
18 days ago

It might be worth checking with AI to see if it is common for rivers to have logs floating in them or not. And considering the investment involved, the insurance company might also have an opinion about it as well. But hey, I don’t want to be a kill joy if someone has enough money that they can simply walk away from the crash and buy another toy.

Ron Wanttaja
Reply to  Jay
18 days ago

According to the NTSB record, the builder of the airplane and the pilot during the accident had the same last name, so I expect the plane was probably built within the family. So they’d spent hundreds, if not thousands of hours building it. I would suspect they had more investment in the airplane than just the dollars.

Jay
Jay
Reply to  Ron Wanttaja
18 days ago

Ouch.