Humility: A Fly Baby Pilot’s Hard Reality Check

Back in ancient Rome, if the commander of a legion gained a great victory, he would be allowed to enter the city in a triumphal parade. Wagons would show the haul of loot, prisoners would wail in their chains, and the general himself would ride in all his polished glory in a great war-chariot.

But with the general rode a slave. The slave was assigned to keep the great victor humble. He’d remind the general that he was a human being, not a god. He’d claim the general’s lorica made his butt look big, claim every good-looking woman who winked at the hero was actually a man, and wrinkle his nose suspiciously every time the chariot passed a stockyard. All during the great parade, the slave would remind the general that he put his toga on one fold at a time, like any other man.

Two thousand years later, we don’t have slaves. We have airplanes instead.

I hadn’t been having a real good day (to start with) and decided to strap on my single-seat, open-cockpit Fly Baby for a quick visit to a nearby airport. I’d flown to that field quite often, but today, the active runway was the opposite of most of my previous visits. I knew, though, that the ground dropped away radically at the approach end, and I’d heard mention of some turbulence.

No matter. I’d been flying Fly Babies for years and had about 500 hours.

But on short final, the bottom dropped out. Airspeed evaporated like dry ice in the Sahara. I slammed the stick to the aft stop, and my left hand started to ram the throttle forward.

Let us pause, for a moment, with the Continental happily idling, the bracing wires singing a gay tune, and a faint whimper rising from the cockpit:

The wings of a Fly Baby are braced through the axle. There’s no “give” in that landing gear, other than what the tires provide.

You see, a Fly Baby doesn’t have a lot of things people expect these days. Doors, a canopy, and pitch trim, etc., were all sacrificed to the goddess of simplicity.

A major thing it doesn’t have is any sort of shock absorption capability in the landing gear. No springy steel. No oleos. No bungees. No “Land-o-Matic.” Just a fraction of an inch of Mr. Goodyear’s best, and a puff or two of air.

So there I was, heading down …

WHAM!

We hit with a slam I hadn’t felt for years. The aircraft rebounded into the air. The Continental finally caught. I kept us from hitting again and established a climb. My gaze shot left and right. Both wings were in place, and landing wires were no slacker than normal. No shouts on the radio about parts left behind. Doubts warred. I had plenty of runway left. Should I pull the power, land, and check the aircraft over?

Just then I looked down into the face of a man who had been working on his airplane. I could see the grin. There had been two airplanes waiting to take off behind me.

Sad to say, that clinched the decision. I didn’t want to be seen; I wanted to climb under a rock somewhere and curse the Wright Brothers. I kept climbing and headed for home, just 7 miles away.

In retrospect, I feel less guilty about my decision not to try to salvage the landing. I was definitely rattled. I could have brought the aircraft around for another approach, but would have had to face the sink again. It was probably better that I took 10 minutes to settle down on the way back to a familiar runway.

I was still jittery as I turned final to my home field. I stayed much too high on approach and ended up in a prolonged slip on short final. I then overflared. The crosswind waggled the nose. I added a bit of power and managed to ease the wheels onto the runway.

My mind unclenched as the Baby rolled out normally. Roll down to the hangar, spin the tail around, and kill the switches.

And then for the first time, I remembered it. One luxury my Fly Baby did have was a recording G-meter. I looked.

The G-meter after the hard landing. The arrow shows the maximum impact recorded. The airplane wasn’t damaged, but the author’s back hurt for a week.

It was pegged at the maximum reading: +4.0 G’s.

With a feeling of dread, I unfolded myself from the cockpit and walked around the wing to examine the gear.

No damage. The axle might have a slight bend to it, but I couldn’t swear the bend hadn’t been there before. No cracks in the wheels, no gouges out of the tires, no stripped bolts, no broken welds, no snapped wires, and the bottom longerons where the gear legs attach flowed with nary a kink. I noticed the rubber cuff around the gas-tank filler tube. The cuff was about a one-eighth inch above the level of the surrounding sheet metal. Either the gas tank flattened slightly on impact, dragging the tube down, or the metal skins flexed and shoved the cuff up.

Either way, that is one strong homebuilt.

I had been feeling like hot stuff. Touch-and-goes had become routine in an aircraft that many find difficult to land smoothly. Maybe I’ve been so full of myself that I haven’t been listening; perhaps the airplane decided that whispering in my ear wasn’t enough. There’s nothing like a nearly bent bird to point out both one’s flaws and one’s mortality.

Any landing you can learn from is a good landing. On that basis, maybe I didn’t do too badly …

Ron Wanttaja
Ron Wanttaja
Ron Wanttaja is a retired space systems engineer. During a 40-year career, he helped design, build, test, launch, and operate 18 spacecraft, including the International Space Station. On the aviation side, he has owned a Bowers Fly Baby since 1996 and flew the original prototype for seven years before acquiring his own. He lives just outside of Portland, Oregon, with his wife, romance novelist Lisa McAllister.

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Latest
Related

10 COMMENTS

Subscribe to this comment thread
Notify of
guest
10 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Carlos151
Carlos151
3 months ago

It happens to all of us regardless of how long we’ve been flying. Thanks for sharing!

Charles P. Steadman
Charles P. Steadman
3 months ago

Good read, Ron. Glad you and your plane can fly another day.

Chris
Chris
3 months ago

In the pattern at Auburn, S50, a February morning with the sun out but still very chilly. A Fly Baby was out in the pattern and a friend asked the pilot over the frequency if it wasn’t a little unpleasant. The pilot stated that comfort was highly overrated.

Ron Wanttaja
Reply to  Chris
3 months ago

As the only guy in a Fly Baby at S50, that was undoubtedly me. 🙂

My Fly Baby has a pretty snug cockpit, and as long as bare skin is shielded from the wind, things aren’t very bad. The windshield deflects most of the wind, and in the ~40 years I’ve been flying open cockpit, I’ve learned what I have to wear to be able to tolerate it. Won’t say, “What I have to wear to stay WARM,” ’cause I know that ain’t gonna happen.

Picture shows my Fly Baby during a stopover at Pierce County Airport. IIRC, the temperature that day was ~15 degrees F. Note the icicles hanging from the Agwagon….

ice4
stephen casciotta
stephen casciotta
Reply to  Ron Wanttaja
2 months ago

no way

JAMES KNOX
3 months ago

Great story, Ron. Thanks for being willing to share. [I still remember the tales you used to share about your 48 cent annual on your Flybaby.] My primary flight instructor (military guy) had a similar tale. First solo down to some little airport, but used to he 300′ by 13K runways at Bergstom AFB, he kept waiting for the runway to get “big” in the windscreen. Wham!!! A few bounces later he got it stopped (still on the runway). Claimed he was so embarrassed that, if there had been anyone watching, he would have just tried to take off without even inspecting the plane!

Jim Frisbie
Jim Frisbie
3 months ago

Ron
Thanks for the story and the illustration from the ancients. I may use that with our Teen Flight students.
Yes. we all have done a “carrier landing” that we feel humbled by. It’s worst when it’s on your home field.

Dan Marotta
Dan Marotta
3 months ago

I slammed the stick to the aft stop, and my left hand started to ram the throttle forward.”

Last time I slammed the stick to the aft stop I was practicing snap rolls!

stephen casciotta
stephen casciotta
2 months ago

any landing you can walk away from right?

Ron Wanttaja
Reply to  stephen casciotta
2 months ago

“Any landing your can walk away from is a good landing. But if you can re-use the airplane, it’s a GREAT landing!” 🙂